While Pip and Harry are at their special places, they both meet friends and foes along the way. Harry meets his two best friends Ron and Hermoine, and also encounters the nefarious Draco Malfoy and that one freak named Snape. Pip meets Herbert, whom he already had known as "the pale young gentleman," and Biddy too. Pip meets a couple of different enemies, such as Trabb's boy and Estella, to name a few, however, none are as extreme as those in J.K. Rowling's work. I think Harry also sees more dangers, trouble, and a fair bit more of action than Pip, but it doesn't mean Great Expectations has no suspense at all. Pip sees convicts fight, scary old ladies, and comes across mystery at every turn. I did think both of the books did show some good mystery. Harry handles situations better, he is brave and outgoing, while Pip is shy, timid, and sensitive, even in his older years. In Harry Potter, you are always left wondering when Snape is going to become the teacher of dark magic, if he is, why is he even in the book, or if Harry ever will face Voldemort and how a battle between them would turn out, and of course, why would J.K. Rowling ever kill Hedwig, Dumbledore, and Dobby. Suspense doesn't mean a thing if the only way you can put it into writing is to kill the most beloved characters of a book.
I hope now that you have read these examples, you now see why I chose Harry Potter for this subject.

I would have never compared this book to Harry Potter! Very creative! I love the idea of Pip having a golden ticket too. I also never thought of how alike their childhoods were.
ReplyDeleteI didn't realize how similar Pip and Harrys' experiences were! They almost parallel one another's lives! Great thinking! :)
ReplyDeleteOne thing I noticed--you didn't mention a central message that was similar in the two works.